Thinking about bringing a German Shepherd into your life? Well, you’re not alone—many people are drawn to their loyalty, intelligence, and protective instincts. But before you take the plunge, it’s essential to know the reasons to own a German Shepherd dog and why they might not be the right fit for every household.
These dogs are as impressive as they are challenging! From their need for constant mental stimulation to their strong protective nature, owning a German Shepherd is an adventure. Let’s dive into the 15 reasons not to get a German Shepherd Dog (GSD), and help you decide if you’re ready for the rewards—and the responsibility—that come with incredible German Shepherd breed!
Why Not to Get a German Shepherd Dog 15 Reasons
1. Intelligence Can Backfire
German Shepherds are often touted as one of the most intelligent dog breeds, and it’s true—they learn quickly and can master commands in no time. However, this intelligence can also backfire if not properly channeled. Without consistent training and structure, these clever dogs may figure out ways to manipulate their owners. They could learn to ignore commands, sneak food from counters, or even develop mischievous habits that are hard to break. If you’re not firm and consistent, you may find yourself outsmarted by your own dog!
2. They Demand a Job
German Shepherds were originally bred for work—whether it’s herding, police tasks, search and rescue, or protection. These are dogs that need a purpose, and if you don’t provide them with one, they may become bored and destructive. Expect to keep them busy with training sessions, agility courses, or daily exercise. If you don’t offer them a way to channel their boundless energy, they might start creating their own “jobs,” like chewing up your shoes or digging up the backyard!
3. Extreme Sensitivity to Owner’s Emotions
German Shepherds as a pet are incredibly attuned to their owner’s emotions. If you’re stressed, anxious, or in a bad mood, your dog will feel it too. This sensitivity can result in your dog mirroring your emotions, which could lead to them becoming anxious, nervous, or unpredictable. If you have a lot of emotional ups and downs, your dog may start reflecting those moods, leading to unwanted behavior or anxiety. It’s a bit like having a furry emotional mirror!
4. They Get Bored Easily
German Shepherds are not the kind of dog that can happily nap all day. They need mental and physical stimulation to stay happy and healthy. If they don’t get enough to do, they can quickly become bored, and boredom in a German Shepherd can result in some seriously destructive behavior. You might find your shoes chewed up, your furniture scratched, or even holes in the garden as they look for ways to entertain themselves. A tired dog is a good dog!
5. Not Suited for First-Time Dog Owners
These dogs are not for the faint of heart or the first-time pet owner. German Shepherds require an experienced handler who knows how to set boundaries and provide consistent training. Without the proper leadership, these intelligent and powerful dogs can easily become dominant, unruly, and hard to manage. If you’re new to dogs, you may find the constant need for attention and training overwhelming.
Read More: 7 Different Types of German Shepherds Dog
6. Strong Territorial Instincts
German Shepherds are natural protectors, and while this makes them excellent guard dogs, it also means they can be overly territorial. They can become aggressive or defensive when strangers enter your home or even bark excessively at visitors. Without proper socialization, this territorial nature can escalate, leading to a dog that’s hard to manage around other people and animals. If you’re not prepared to deal with this protective instinct, you might find your dog constantly on edge.
7. Highly Reactive to Stimuli
German Shepherds are always on alert, thanks to their sharp senses and heightened awareness of their surroundings. Unfortunately, this means they can react strongly to unfamiliar stimuli. Loud noises, sudden movements, or even new people can set them off, leading to barking, pacing, or anxious behavior. In busy or chaotic environments, they may feel overwhelmed, and their reactivity could escalate to aggression. If you live in a bustling area or have a lot of visitors, this can be quite a challenge.
8. Need a Strict Routine
German Shepherds thrive on structure and consistency. They feel safest when their day is predictable, with set times for meals, walks, and training. If your schedule is erratic or you frequently change your routine, your dog may become anxious or disoriented. Inconsistent feeding times, erratic exercise schedules, or lack of a structured environment can lead to behavioral problems, making these dogs better suited for people who lead a stable, predictable lifestyle.
9. They Can Be Escape Artists
If you don’t have a secure yard, a German Shepherd will find a way out! Known for their problem-solving skills and high energy levels, these dogs are notorious escape artists. Whether it’s climbing a fence, digging underneath it, or even learning how to open gates, German Shepherds will stop at nothing to get out and explore. Make sure your yard is “escape-proof,” or else you’ll find yourself constantly chasing after your curious pup!
10. Can Develop Over-Attachment
While German Shepherds are incredibly loyal and affectionate, this loyalty can sometimes turn into over-attachment. They can develop severe separation anxiety when left alone for long periods of time, often leading to destructive behaviors like chewing, barking, or even depression. Their strong bond with their owners makes them prone to emotional distress when they’re not around, so you’ll need to invest time in helping them feel secure when you’re not home.
11. Not Always Good with Small Children
German Shepherds can be great family dogs, but their size, strength, and herding instincts may make them a bit too much for small children. Their exuberance during playtime may lead to accidental knocks or bumps, and their instinct to herd can cause them to nip at a child’s heels. Proper training and supervision are necessary to ensure that they behave appropriately around younger members of the family.
12. High Risk of Genetic Disorders
German Shepherds, like many purebred dogs, are susceptible to certain genetic health issues. Hip dysplasia is well-known in the breed, but they are also prone to epilepsy, degenerative myelopathy, and heart disease. These conditions can lead to expensive vet bills and emotional distress as your dog’s health deteriorates. Regular veterinary check-ups and a proactive approach to health management are crucial for keeping your Shepherd healthy.
13. They Can Be Too Protective
While their protective nature is a major advantage in certain situations, it can also become a challenge. If not properly socialized, German Shepherds can become overly protective, exhibiting aggressive behavior towards strangers or other animals. This can create a stressful environment, especially in social situations or when introducing new people to your home. Early socialization is key to preventing overprotectiveness from becoming a problem.
14. They Shed Year-Round
German Shepherds have a thick double coat that sheds constantly. Expect to deal with hair on your furniture, clothes, and floors no matter what time of year it is. While regular brushing can help manage the shedding, it’s a reality you’ll need to live with. If you’re a clean freak or have allergies, a German Shepherd’s shedding might become a major inconvenience.
15. Potential for Legal Liability
Due to their strong bite and reputation as working dogs, German Shepherds are sometimes subject to breed-specific legislation in certain areas, which can make ownership more complicated. Some insurance companies may have breed restrictions, and if your dog becomes aggressive, it could lead to legal consequences. It’s important to check local laws and be prepared for the potential legal issues that come with owning a breed like the German Shepherd.
German Shepherds are incredible, loyal companions, but they are not the right fit for everyone. They require an experienced, dedicated owner who is willing to commit time and effort to their training, exercise, and overall well-being. If you are not prepared for the challenges they bring, it may be best to consider a breed that better suits your lifestyle.
